Hosted by IDTechEx
Advanced Batteries & Energy Storage Research
Posted on March 4, 2020 by  & 

Powin Energy

History

Powin Energy ('Powin') was originally founded as Powin Corporation in 1989 by Joseph Lu and is based in Oregon, USA. Initially, the company manufactured, designed and provided logistics for consumer goods companies outsourcing production to China and Taiwan. Products were wide-ranging, varying from treadmills to gun safes.
 
Powin Corp began R&D for stationary energy storage in 2011, which became the sole focus in 2016. Despite its previous business being unrelated to energy, the company developed an expertise in supply chain logistics in Asia and applied this to its energy storage business. Indeed, it has leveraged deep connections to secure unique supply-side partnerships, such as with battery maker CATL.
 
Although initially a private company, Powin went public in 2010 as 'Powin Corp'. In 2016 this became 'Powin Energy Corp', or 'Powin Energy', with the renewed focus on stationary energy storage. In 2018, Powin Energy filed to become private once again, citing that its capital is mainly raised from affiliates and it would save money not having to produce yearly disclosures.
 
Today, Powin Energy targets scalable energy storage solutions for utilities, commercial & industrial sites, and EV fast-charging stations.

Technology

Powin Energy designs and assembles battery modules, packs and the final turnkey energy storage system using naked cells outsourced from battery makers in China. A controller is added to each module to balance charge across cells, and to each pack to balance charge across modules.
 
 
The company develops custom software for the Battery Management System (BMS), Energy Management System (EMS) and the Powin Cloud:
 
  • The BMS layer ensures DC components of the system are operating within safe margins, and that core battery reporting is correct.
  • An AC Battery App is an app framework for the safe operation of the BESS. It is used for power and voltage control, and helps manage the BMS as the battery is used for different applications.
  • The EMS is above the AC Battery App. It has the ability to monitor environmental factors and control all the critical equipment and power electronics within the system.
  • The Powin Cloud securely receives data from all of the above, stores it and presents it in an operations user-interface.
 
Developing custom software has led to many competitive advantages; for example, Powin commented the BMS used on other energy storage systems were based on BMS designs for electric vehicles (charge moves between internal cells for balancing). Powin's BMS uses AC power from the grid to balance the cells more effectively.
 
The company utilises LFP Li-ion cells 'for the safety component': it is harder for LFP cells to reach thermal runaway (versus NMC), and a lower cell voltage means energy is released more slowly in a thermal runaway event.
 
Another advantage is the manufacturing plants for LFP cells in China are highly mature, as LFP was the dominant Li-ion chemistry used in the early stages of China's electric car market.
 
 
In March 2019, Powin secured a supply contract for 1.85GWh of LFP battery cells from CATL through 2022. This is a unique agreement, and Powin is one of two companies to reach a deal with CATL outside of automotive applications. Components outside the 'DC box' are also manufactured by a third party; for example, inverters and converters are sourced from tier 1 suppliers such as SMA.
 
Before 2019, Powin sold an energy storage system branded eTrust for applications requiring no more than one-hour duration with a 1C or 2C power rate. The eTrust system utilised LFP cells from LISHEN, a smaller battery-maker also from China.
 
With CATL, the company's new energy storage products for 2020 have two-hour or four-hour durations, following the general market trend amid high demand for long-duration energy storage.
 
Powin's BMS and other control software / hardware is technically battery-agnostic and could be applied to NMC systems. However, for the time being, Powin is likely to stick with LFP only. With NMC, it is difficult to predict individual cell age compared to LFP, which has a flat, predictable voltage profile during charge / discharge (throughout cell lifetime). It is therefore relatively easy to augment an LFP system, and difficult to augment an NMC system (where new battery cells would be prone to accelerated ageing next to degraded cells).
 
 
Powin begins testing its new energy storage system at the stack level in December 2019 and expects its first deliveries in Q1 2020.

Powin Module

 
Image source: Powin Energy

Powin Stack225

 
Image source: Powin Energy

Key Metrics

Product metrics
Release
Year
Power (kW)
Capacity (kWh)
Dur. (Hrs)
VDC
Chem.
No. Stacks
No. Cells
No. Modules
Cooling
Op. Temp (C)
Cell Supplier
Stack140
2016
140
140
1
760-990
LFP
1
1088
17
-
-
LISHEN
Stack225
2020
113
225
2
739-963
LFP
1
264
11
-
-
CATL
Block 2.1 (40 Ft Container)
2016
2240
2240
1
762-993
LFP
16
17,408
272
Forced Air & HVAC
-30 to +50
LISHEN
Block 3.1 (40 Ft Container)
2020
1575
3150
2
739-963
LFP
14
3696
154
Forced Air & HVAC
-30 to +50
CATL

Business Model and Market

Powin currently sells energy storage systems directly to customers but will trial leasing options in 2020. It can sell DC stacks – a housing containing Li-ion modules for indoor use – or a turnkey, containerised energy storage system for outdoors, in DC or AC configurations.
 
 
The company's first grid-scale project was its 2MW / 8MWh Millikan Avenue system in Irvine California. This was contracted in August 2016 and became operational in January 2017. It began participating in the California Independent System Operator (CAISO) wholesale market, which lead Powin to develop a 'bidding optimisation' software, which can stand-alone separate to its hardware business.
 
Powin has 200MWh of energy storage commissioned YTD, and expects to double this in 2020 with an additional 200MWh-300MWh; it projects a further doubling of contracted energy storage in 2021.
 
In the USA, Powin is targeting California, Arizona, Hawaii, Massachusetts and New York. In central America, Powin has a 12MWh project in Mexico; in RoW, the company is targeting Australia & Europe (Italy & Spain).
 
The price of an uninstalled turnkey system depends on volume: for orders above 20MWh, Powin would price its system aggressively at lower than USD200 per kWh for a DC containerised solution (sold in 2020).
 
Systems under 20MWh would be priced at USD250-300 per kWh (also sold in 2020).
 
Powin's nameplate production capacity is 750MWh in Taiwan. This is expanding in 2020 to an undisclosed amount.

Company Financials

Funding
Privately funded through existing business and affiliates.
Revenue
Powin's revenues more than tripled year-on-year to USD18 million in 2018, up from USD5.7 million in 2017.
Size
88 employees (43 US and 55 China).
Main Assets
Seven patents; software capabilities; network & connections established in Asia.
Profitability
IDTechEx believes the company is profitable.

Partners

SupplierComments
Contemporary Amperex Technology Co. Limited (CATL)In March 2019 it was announced that CATL will supply LFP battery cells for Powin's new Stack225 for at least the next 1.85GWh of sales.

SWOT

Strengths
  • Complete control on system design above the cell level.
  • Strong on software: developed software in-house for BMS, EMS & Powin Cloud as well as for battery operation to generate revenue streams in select markets.
  • USD200 per kWh for a large-scale turnkey system (uninstalled) is very competitive.
Weaknesses
  • Using LFP technology may well be an advantage today, and it could help with marketing the battery as 'safer'. However, IDTechEx has spoken with tier 1 battery makers that point out NMC based Li-ion is more deeply understood and is being developed much faster. This is because NMC is today's dominant battery technology choice for electric cars, and IDTechEx predicts this will continue for at least the next five years, and probably the next ten years. Moreover, no widely adopted Li-ion battery is inherently safe: all use the liquid electrolyte, which is what burns.
Opportunities
  • The large number of countries Powin is targeting reflects the abundant opportunities opening up to energy storage vendors globally.
Threats
  • Using a single battery supplier for the core product line-up makes Powin vulnerable to supply-side price increases. Powin has no leverage over CATL.

IDTechEx Index

Product Value Proposition
9
  • A competitive product with excellent software offerings at one of the lowest prices IDTechEx has seen for stationary energy storage (at the system level). However, this is a predicted price and may increase once installations begin.
State of Technology/Product Development
7
  • Roughly 200MWh of installations in the field, but this is with older products.
  • Module testing for the new Stack140 begins in December 2019, and initial deliveries are planned to start in Q1 2020.
Medium-Term Commercial Opportunity
9
  • Ample opportunity; there is a growing demand for energy storage on the grid in the home market of the USA and globally.
IP and Know-How
7
  • Seven patents; know-how is low compared with the competition as the company has roughly three years of experience deploying batteries. However, it is building its installations portfolio rapidly.
Competitive Landscape
6
  • The stationary energy storage business is highly competitive. Powin stands out with a unique battery supply agreement, low price and strong software offerings, but it will nevertheless be tough.
 
 
CATL entering the supply chain will benefit the industry dominated by only a few giants.
Score [0-10]

Authored By:

Principal Technology Analyst

Posted on: March 4, 2020

More IDTechEx Journals